Alternatives go mainstream:
PRIVATE and ALTERNATIVE MARKETS
sponsored by
Private and alternative markets are fast-becoming a cornerstone of high-net-worth clients’ portfolios and look set to grab an even bigger share as private banks focus on providing more liquid versions of their strategies. Heightened volatility in public equity and bond markets, as the Federal Reserve begins tightening amid soaring inflation, is leading investors to increasingly seek diversification. From providing alternative income sources, to uncorrelated growth opportunities and fresh ways to tap into long-term themes, private markets are appealing to a broader range of investors than ever. In our first publication of 2022, we take a look at how private banks are structuring yield products to deliver better liquidity and check out what KKR is lining up for the private client channel. We also cast our eyes over Hong Kong and Singapore entering the Spac fray and a potential resurgence in the office property market. Our digizines have been revamped to be more interactive and we hope you like the new format and throughout the year we’ll be bringing you a selection of special themed publications both in print and digizine format.
Editor's note
Back to top
Read more
Markus Egloff, head of Asia wealth at KKR, discusses why private equity and infrastructure investments are no longer the preserve of institutions and how he is targeting private bank customers.
Chapter two
content by: Nuveen
Hotter-than-expected inflation is stoking investment opportunities in real estate, according to Nuveen, one of the world’s largest and most experienced real estate investors.
Credit Suisse’s head of private and alternative markets Alois Mueller highlights the big income opportunity and why he wants a private equity manager that’s seen the bad vintages as well as the good.
Chapter one
CONTENTS:
James Phillipps
Investment Editor, Asia
There have been question marks over the future of offices as working from home became the norm, but are they set for a resurgence as economies reopen and investors hunt for income?
Chapter four
content by: SSGA
Hear from State Street Global Advisors’ Jean-François Mesnard-Sense and Viktor Östebo of Flow Traders as they shine a light on the ins and outs of cross-border trading and lessons learned from a year of market upswings and record flows.
Hong Kong and Singapore may be latecomers to the special purpose acquisition company (Spac) party, but they have learnt from the mistakes made by the US in rushing to encourage their launch.
Chapter three
Senior investors from four leading private banks explain how they marry their clients’ ESG concerns with private market investments.
Chapter five
How private assets can become a cornerstone of portfolios
A big challenge for private banks, in a world of high inflation and rising interest rates, is finding investments that not only provide income to clients, but also offer a degree of liquidity. Credit Suisse’s Alois Mueller believes a blend of uncorrelated alternatives are the solution and a standout opportunity. The Swiss bank’s head of private and alternative markets in Asia Pacific has been building up its liquid alternatives proposition since his remit expanded in September. Previously head of private equity, based in Zurich, he also took on the Apac alternative markets beat, which includes hedge funds, and moved over to Hong Kong. Mueller sought to replicate the success he’d had overhauling the private equity funds platform by expanding the range and introducing new fund structures to provide a greater variety of products. ‘On the liquid alternatives side, we also enlarged the offering, especially adding yield alternatives and that is the big opportunity coming, especially here in Apac,’ he said. Income investors, their numbers swelling from the region’s demographics, have had a rough ride in recent times. After years of being stung by low interest rates, they have recently faced the challenge of inflation hitting multi-year highs in many countries.
Meeting demand The prospect of higher interest rates in much of Apac, as the US began its tightening cycle in mid-March, poses a particular headache for yield-hungry bond investors. Add in the Chinese property sector creaking under the strain of debt and extreme volatility in the stock market and it is easy to see why Mueller believes there is strong demand for uncorrelated yield products. He sees opportunities to blend different income-producing assets, including bonds, property and infrastructure to deliver a diversified source of yield. The challenge is then to manage their differing liquidity profiles, combining them into open-ended funds offering regular dealing windows. ‘[We’re looking at] yield alternative structures where you invest into a portfolio comprising maybe properties or credit exposures or infrastructure exposure and you have a structure which allows some form of liquidity,’ Mueller said. ‘It may not quite pay a fixed coupon like a bond and you may get a variable cash payout every year. We hope for 7-8% per annum, but in some years it may only pay 5%. ‘It also may not be as liquid as selling it every day, but if you want to have some of it, you may be able to sell it every quarter – it will be open-ended and clients appreciate that.’ Mueller also expects demand for private credit to increase as more conservative investors with significant exposure to traditional bonds look to diversify. Already bruised by last year’s losses – with the Morningstar Global Core Bond index down 5.7% and the local currency JP Morgan GBI Emerging Market Bond benchmark slumping 8.8% – the fear is rising rates will mean they take a further hit. ‘With rising interest rates, if you are sitting on a traditional bond portfolio, you may have some problems,’ he said. ‘But if you are in a private credit fund, for example, that is providing Libor plus, that is a one-to-three-months exposure, then it gets repriced so you're protected from rising rates at least to a large extent, so that’s attractive.’
by James Phillipps
Alternative energy
chapter one
Winds of change
Private and alternative markets
On the liquid alternatives side, we also enlarged the offering, especially adding yield alternatives and that is the big opportunity coming, especially here in Apac.
Reasons to be upbeat Despite the doom and gloom, exacerbated by the Russia-Ukraine war and soaring commodity prices, Mueller said he remains upbeat about the prospects for private equity. Credit Suisse is currently selecting funds for this year’s flagship strategy, which will combine eight third-party funds, including buyout and special situations mandates. The Seasons Global Program, which has an annualised target return of 15% net, is now in its sixth year and Mueller remains as excited as ever about its prospects. ‘I’m upbeat as long as you stick with the good players and have the ability to find and access them for clients. We don’t go with fly-by-night, flavour-of-the-month or a new theme completely unproven, that’s not what we're looking for,’ he said. ‘We like to go with funds that have a long history where you can check how they did. We give money to people who’ve seen the glorious days, but have also shown how to deliver in a bad vintage.’ One fund his team is looking at is the firm’s eighth vintage, which means the manager ‘has probably been in the private equity business for 35 years’, Mueller said. The manager selection process includes due diligence on all the past deals the managers backed to remove the ‘luck factor’.
welcome
chapter two
chapter three
Alois Mueller, Credit Suisse
Alois Mueller Head of private and alternative markets in Asia Pacific, Credit Suisse
Hong Kong challenges Mueller has had to contend with a general rise in risk aversion since he relocated to Hong Kong last autumn, after a torrid 2021 for Chinese assets that has continued into this year. The move marked a return to the special administrative region for Mueller, who had previously worked there for around seven years in stints at UBS, Rothschild and while briefly running his own consultancy in the 2010s. The choice was not difficult, being nearer his wife’s family in her native Philippines and underlining the bank’s commitment to Asia Pacific, but the Covid restrictions have been. When Mueller met Citywire Asia in Singapore earlier this month, it was the first time he had been out of Hong Kong since moving back. ‘It’s difficult because it makes it very tricky to go and see clients and it maybe doesn’t add to the mood when they’re thinking about long-term investment,’ he said. ‘At one point, the local stock market index reached the lowest levels in years, so investors are a bit shellshocked and are hunkering down.’
This is designed to ensure private equity funds generated returns from a broad spread of investments, which is much more repeatable than a manager who just got lucky on a single holding that skyrocketed. In buyout funds he looks for gross multiples of two to two-and-a-half times, so that the net to clients is around 1.8 times. Mueller rejects the well-worn argument that returns from private assets will necessarily come down over time as more and more investors pile into this area. He argues the total market, across private equity, private credit, private real estate, venture capital and beyond, continues to grow at such a pace it can absorb the increasing inflows. ‘The universe of investment opportunities has expanded dramatically and if you look at the ratio of what gets invested in and what’s available to be invested, from 2010 there has been very little change,’ he said. ‘We’ve had a period of relative stability since 2010 and I don’t know if the current situation [means] those commitments don’t just flow so freely anymore. But I expect there to be a lot of opportunities in the next two years, particularly around climate change, where the big action will be private.’
Credit Suisse’s Alois Mueller explains why the Swiss bank’s cocktail of uncorrelated alternatives will hit the spot for income-thirsty investors gasping for yield
Content from: nuveen
Content from: SSGA
Why private real estate in an inflationary environment?
Advertisement feature
CONTENT BY
As a top five real estate manager globally [1] with a long and proven history in investing in the asset class, we have experienced many market cycles. We believe real estate may be the right investment for today’s investor. That conviction is based on five compelling factors: income, growth potential, volatility management, diversification and inflation protection potential. Real estate has historically offered investors a higher level of income than other asset classes. It has generated strong risk-adjusted total returns with a risk/return profile that is different to other asset classes and typically with less volatility.
Morningstar Global Sustainable Fund Flows - Q2 2020
By offering capital appreciation and income opportunities when inflation rises, real estate has traditionally acted as a hedge against inflation. That is a persuasive narrative in today’s macroeconomic environment. The annual rate of inflation in the US accelerated to 7.5% in January 2022 – the highest since February 1982 – as soaring energy costs, labor shortages and supply disruptions propelled the Consumer Price Index higher. While some inflationary pressures are likely to fade as the Covid-19 pandemic ends, others may prove more persistent. On one hand, supply chain bottlenecks may be transitory in nature. On the other, energy prices have risen significantly and may likely stay that way for the foreseeable future. Additionally, long-term demographic trends and Covid-driven behaviors – chief among them the ‘Great Resignation’ as record numbers of people leave their jobs in the wake of the pandemic – could lead to a permanently smaller workforce and therefore stickier wage inflation. Real returns Real estate investments may be seen as inflation-proofed in a variety of ways. The value of real estate is derived fundamentally from the cash flow they generate. The higher the cash flow, the higher the value and the higher the returns to investors. In an inflationary environment, landlords often have the ability to increase rents and therefore cash flow. Many long-term leases, such as those seen in commercial properties, typically have built-in rent escalators that protect real income generation. Additionally, higher wages tend to lead to more consumer spending, which is a plus for single-family and multi-family residential housing – one of the key areas of opportunity that we have identified in the market. Further, as a direct real estate manager, we have the control required to manage rising costs. We can use our flexibility to improve operations and focus on new technologies to mitigate higher costs. Finally, spiking labor costs, increased material costs and severe supply shortages have made the delivery of new buildings very difficult. As a result, it will be more difficult for supply to catch up with demand, leading to increased pricing power for landlord. Fundamentally, we see a lot of alpha in the market. The pandemic has not caused a paradigm shift for real estate, rather, it has accelerated pre-existing trends. High household savings ratios around the globe stand to re-inflate real estate markets as Covid-19 relinquishes its grip on communities and economies. That should drive demand for housing, ecommerce and services, giving further support to those sectors that rebounded the fastest and sharpest from the property price falls seen during the early days of the pandemic (see chart). We believe this trajectory has further to go.
[1] 1 ANREV/INREV/NCREIF Fund Manager Survey 2021. [2] Left: As of 31 Dec 2021. NCREIF, 4Q20; Bloomberg. Commercial property is represented by the income component of the NFI-ODCE Index, US equities are represented by the dividend yield of the S&P 500 Index, U.S. investment grade bonds are represented by the yield to maturity of the Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond Index, and U.S. T-Bills are represented by 3 month U.S. T-Bills. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Right: As of 31 Dec 2021. NCREIF, Bloomberg. Volatility is represented by standard deviation. Standard Deviation is a measure of the dispersion of a set of data from its mean. The more spread apart the data, the higher the deviation and volatility. [3] Assets under management as of 31 December 2021
[2]
As per slide 2 of ‘The opportunity in real estate’
Shawn Lese Chief investment officer and head of funds management, Americas, Nuveen Real Estate
Long legacy As the recovery continues, selectivity becomes more important. Our aptitude in locating the best investment opportunities has been developed during our 88-year legacy in real estate investing. Today, we have unparalleled reach – a global real estate presence with strong local expertise. More than 725 employees located in 30 cities in the United States, Europe and Asia Pacific use their deep geographical and sector knowledge to collectively manage $152bn [3] in real estate assets. Our strategies invest in tomorrow’s world. That is because they have been developed with an understanding of the structural trends that will shape and impact the future of real estate. Our global cities strategy focuses on real estate in the most promising locations for future growth – from Austin, Texas to Berlin in Germany and Sydney, Australia. A robust proprietary research process filters the world’s cities based on four metrics: scale, transparency, stability and megatrends. This pinpoints cities with a metropolitan area population of more than 150,000. Their real estate markets have the necessary liquidity, data availability, property rights and good transaction processes to facilitate investment. Their countries have adequate political and economic stability. And, finally, we believe they are in the top 2% cities globally that are best positioned to benefit from global megatrends: urbanization, rising middle classes, aging population, growing economic power of the East, technology and sustainability. As an investment manager, we are dedicated to sustainability. Sustainability objectives are integrated in our investment process and we are committed to having a net-zero carbon global property portfolio by 2040.
Dynamic segments Our strategic focus is on the most dynamic segments of the market: industrial, housing and alternative real estate such as healthcare facilities. One theme that drives the allocation is the exodus from coastal cities into the Sun Belt – across the Carolinas, Georgia and Texas. It will have implications for real estate values in many sectors, including housing, office, industrial and technology centers. Healthcare transformation, meanwhile, is driving demand for life science facilities focused on medical research and medical offices to provide the aging baby-boomer generation of nearly 73 million people with innovative outpatient care. Another powerful theme is the acceleration in the adoption of ecommerce, which continues to drive demand for warehouse leasing. For example, we own and manage One National, a 300,000-square-foot warehouse in Boston, Massachusetts, which Amazon is using as a middle-mile sorting center. Click here to learn more about what Nuveen offers in real estate, as well as across a range of other alternative investments.
Hotter-than-expected inflation is stoking investment opportunities in real estate, according to Nuveen, one of the world’s largest and most experienced real estate investors
There is no reason why private equity and infrastructure investments should be excluded from private wealth portfolios, according to Markus Egloff, alternative asset manager and KKR’s head of wealth in Asia. Most of the strategies currently in the market are focused on real estate and private debt, but Egloff believes this can be expanded to include other asset classes that have traditionally been the preserve of institutions. To drive this opportunity, the private markets giant has been building out its team. In Asia, Egloff expects the headcount to grow to more than 10 in key markets such as Singapore, Hong Kong and Japan, to support rising interest from individual investors. KKR, which has $471bn in total assets, was an early entrant in both Asia and the private wealth space and opened its first offices in the region in 2005. Its assets under management in Asia-dedicated strategies have increased from $20bn to $42bn in the last two years, according to the group’s fourth quarter earnings call held in February. This year the firm will be raising capital for five strategies in infrastructure, real estate, credit and growth. Last year, it closed the KKR Asian Fund IV, a $15bn private equity vehicle focused on the region. It also raised $1.7bn for its first Asia real estate fund. In private wealth, the firm oversees more than $50bn in assets.
Demand for infrastructure There is a particular demand for infrastructure strategies, Egloff said, as investors seek both income-generating assets and those that can provide protection in a higher inflationary environment. KKR currently oversees some $40bn in infrastructure assets globally and has made about 65 related investments in a range of sub-sectors and geographies. In mid-March, the firm raised $17bn for its Global Infrastructure Investors IV fund, more than twice the $7.4bn attracted by its predecessor in 2018. ‘One big way to mitigate the uncertainty we see in the market today is to get the long-term investment themes right,’ Egloff said. ‘For us, this means focusing on the opportunities around energy transition and security, cyber and digitalisation, automation and logistics, and the rise of the global millennial, among others,’ he added.
by Nithya Subramanian
Expanding the notion of private wealth portfolios
Our consumers and investors are tech-savvy and we see a huge opportunity to reach more of them through digital channels and innovative platforms that seek to democratise the alternative investment space
Markus Egloff, KKR
Markus Egloff Head of wealth in Asia, KKR
The rise of India India is an important part of KKR’s investment strategy in the region, Egloff said. The firm opened its Mumbai office in 2009. Since then, the country has become a popular destination for private equity firms. In 2021, there were 1,201 private equity and venture capital deals in India, worth $62.8bn, according to the Chartered Alternative Investment Analyst Association, up from 853 deals worth $23.9bn in 2017. In November, the firm appointed veteran banker KV Kamath as a senior adviser for India. KKR was also the lead investor in LivSpace, a home interior and renovation platform that raised $180m in its Series F fundraising in February. Other investments in the country include Virescent Infrastructure, a renewable energy platform, Vini Cosmetics, JB Chemicals, and Reliance Retail and Jio Platforms, both units of Reliance Industries. Jio Platforms houses the group’s telecommunication and digital business. The growth of innovative and disruptive Indian companies and generational transitions have created opportunities across the asset classes, Egloff said, singling out global and export-driven businesses and sectors such as technology, consumer, healthcare, and financial services. ‘We see terrific opportunity in India due to the dynamic population and strong economic fundamentals that are fueling the growth of innovative and disruptive homegrown companies,’ he added. ‘These tailwinds have also been boosted by progressive reforms that encourage investment across sectors, as well as trends around consumption upgrades and the digitalisation of traditional industries.’
Traditionally, this channel has contributed about 10-20% of funds annually, but this is expected to grow to 30-50%. For Egloff, digitisation will be a game changer in the private wealth space. ‘Our consumers and investors are tech-savvy and we see a huge opportunity to reach more of them through digital channels and innovative platforms that seek to democratise the alternative investment space,’ he said. ‘We’re also starting to see credible digital native distribution platforms emerge due to global developments in the blockchain and tokenisation space and see wider adoption in the coming years.’ The firm has had dedicated working groups studying different models, including in Asia, Egloff said, as he pointed out that they want to be at the forefront of the evolution and are willing to partner with strong players in different segments. Indeed, last year, KKR took an undisclosed minority stake in fintech iCapital Network – a global platform that helps firms distribute private markets funds to individual investors. KKR has also been investing in data architecture and management, as well as systems that will help make its sales process more seamless and efficient. In addition, it’s been working on improving its distribution technology and striking partnerships with players it predicts will become disruptors in the space.
KKR’s Markus Egloff believes private wealth investors are ready for a more innovative use of their funds and he’s building out his Asia team accordingly
The Hong Kong and Singapore stock exchanges are adopting a more disciplined approach to attract the best quality special purpose acquisition companies (Spacs) and avoid some of the problems seen in the US markets. But with so many jurisdictions now vying to tempt lucrative blank-cheque companies to their country, it is uncertain if they’ll succeed in creating a vibrant market. ‘There is still a buzz and energy around Spacs as a product, but how much interest there will be for Spacs in Singapore and Hong Kong is hard to tell now, as both regimes are quite new,’ said Carolyn Sng, a partner at law firm K&L Gates. Aquila Acquisition Corp became the first Spac to list in Hong Kong last month, but closed down 3.2% on its debut and ended March in the red. Spacs took off in the US during the pandemic. Since the start of 2020, there have been 912 Spac initial public offerings (IPOs), raising a total of $255.5bn. Some of these were backed by Asia-based sponsors, who until recently didn’t have the option to list a vehicle in either Singapore or Hong Kong. They were wildly popular last year, with big celebrity names like Serena Williams and Jay-Z getting involved, but investors have cooled on the structure, as their performance lagged and some even faced litigation. The Spac process has been viewed as a convenient alternative to the traditional IPO because it enables companies to skip the extensive review process that is usually required for a stock exchange listing. However, this can result in companies making potentially fraudulent claims in order to access the market more easily. There have been several examples of such issues, with electric truck maker Nikola paying $125m to the US Securities & Exchange Commission to settle fraud charges, and Lucid Motors coming under investigation. Ed Bennett, a partner at K&L Gates Straits Law in Singapore, said Hong Kong and Singapore learnt from this and the tighter rules they have introduced could become a competitive advantage. ‘The potential investor claims that seem to be at the front of people’s minds with some Spacs may be less of an issue with tighter regulations for Spac listings in Asia. [That tighter regulation] could even become a significant advantage for Spacs listed in Asia, if the wider appetite remains,’ he said.
Different rules The Singapore Exchange established its listing regime for Spacs in September, making it the first stock exchange to allow the vehicles in Asia. Three had listed by the end of February. In December, the Hong Kong Stock Exchange announced the final rules of its new listing regime for Spacs, which came into effect on 1 January, with Aquila the first to list. There are key differences between the two Asian financial hubs’ regimes, as well as how they compare with the US, UK and European rules. Hong Kong Spac IPOs are only open to professional investors, whereas retail investors can participate in Singapore, following the US approach. In addition, at the time of listing, a Spac in Hong Kong must have at least one sponsor that is a licensed intermediary and owns at least 10%, as well as two directors with specific Securities and Futures Commission licences. Hong Kong Spacs are also required to raise private investment in public equity (Pipe) – a common feature in the US but certainly not a legal requirement. Spacs in Singapore also have several rules designed to align the interests of founding shareholders and the management team with the investors. These include a minimum subscription requirement for founding shareholders and management teams. There is a moratorium period on the sale of their shares and Spacs have a minimum market capitalisation requirement set at $150m. There is also a limit on the sponsor’s ‘promote’, the practice of receiving shares for free or for a nominal value. ‘Both regimes were devised to cater for demand. But because both jurisdictions have retail-based markets, the Spac regimes they offer are different from the US,’ Sng said. ‘In Hong Kong, the regulators have made it clear they want to attract the bigger, high quality Spac targets. The Spac regime is another avenue for companies to get listed in Hong Kong; it’s about offering different options for potential targets and listing vehicles,’ she added.
by Selin Bucak
Tough rules could be a trump card for Asian Spacs
Spac targets One of the first Spacs to list in Singapore was Pegasus Asia, sponsored by European asset manager Tikehau Capital and LVMH chairman Bernard Arnault’s holding firm Financière Agache, which raised S$170m ($125m). Tikehau saw an opportunity to launch a Spac in a new market where it has strong existing relationships. It also wanted to move outside the saturated US market, according to Neil Parekh, head of Asia, Australia and New Zealand at Tikehau. The stricter rules in Singapore were also a draw for the France-headquartered group, rather than a problem. ‘SGX’s framework deliberately scrutinises the track record of sponsors and requires them to invest in their Spacs, and as a firm we are always looking to ensure alignment of interest with investors that fit in with the SGX framework,’ Parekh said. ‘The new Spac regulations in Singapore create a commercially viable framework that also provides adequate guard rails to protect investors and make it an attractive market to consider for companies in the region.’
A stricter regime may play into Hong Kong and Singapore’s hands as they try to entice investors away from a saturated US Spacs market
Carolyn Sng Partner, K&L Gates
Ed Bennett Partner, K&L Gates Straits Law
Neil Parekh Head of Asia, Australia and New Zealand, Tikehau Capital
Investment in Asia-Pacific commercial real estate is set to rise in 2022 spurred by the demand for high quality buildings as employees trickle back to the office and rents and occupancies stabilise. Despite the work-from-home trend and pandemic restrictions, regional investment in the office sector hit $74bn in 2021, a 17% rise from the previous year’s level, according to property consultant Jones Lang Lasalle (JLL). Overall, commercial real estate investment climbed 26% to $177bn, returning to pre-pandemic levels. Offices remain Asia Pacific’s most sought after commercial real estate asset, said JLL, forecasting investment in the sector to grow by 20%-30% this year. ‘Investors remain underinvested in Asia Pacific property’ and there is ‘strong conviction to increase exposure in 2022 with a real focus on larger deals and platform acquisitions,’ said Stuart Crow, CEO, capital markets, Asia Pacific, JLL. Singapore, Tokyo and the major Chinese cities are the favoured locations for office real estate. Factors such as quality, safety, environmental standards and the use of smart technology are increasingly skewing interest towards grade A office buildings, rather than ageing stock with older specifications. Analysts expect more companies to relocate to better-equipped office buildings with staff welfare in mind, supporting rents. In the largest deal in Singapore last year, One George Street, a 23-storey grade A office tower in the heart of the central business district with a green rating from the local authorities, was bought by JP Morgan and Nuveen Real Estate for $935.7m in November.
The preference for grade A buildings also stems from the fact that tenants tend to sign longer leases and ‘there is certainty of income from creditworthy tenants,’ said Yvonne Siew, head of real estate advisory and investments at Bank of Singapore. Although the very future of offices has been called into question after many workers found they preferred working from home during lockdowns, a number of companies are starting to encourage workers to return to the workplace by offering a hybrid working model. Tech firms such as Apple, Google and Twitter have already set dates for reopening their offices in the region. In cities such as Hong Kong and Singapore, where homes tend to be small and travelling distances short, the impetus to head back to the office is greater as they reopen. ‘The government in Singapore is clearly pushing people to go back to the office, not least because it helps reinvigorate the retail malls around the downtown office area,’ said Shern-Ling Koh, a portfolio manager at Principal Global Investors. ‘But I think the other offsetting factor that we are seeing, certainly speaking to the office landlords, is that not many of the tenants have actually started downsizing. Even if people are still working from home, during the few times that they go back to the office they need the space for meetings and breakout rooms to take conference calls.’
Offices are back in business
chapter four
The government in Singapore is clearly pushing people to go back to the office, not least because it helps reinvigorate the retail malls around the downtown office area
Cities to watch Looking at offices across the large Asian cities, investor demand for Singapore remains buoyed by the growing number of family offices and the relocation of expatriates from Hong Kong. Despite the regulatory uncertainty and associated risks in China, it is unlikely that affected tenants like those in the tech sector will move out of their offices, say analysts. China’s housing market has been rocked by plummeting sales and developer defaults on billions of dollars of debt, but demand for commercial real estate, especially grade A offices, recovered in 2021. The pace of decline in rents is slowing in cities like Beijing and there will be few opportunities for tenants to expand and relocate at lower rates, said JLL.
Property investors are rubbing their hands as demand for grade A commercial premises continues to rise in the region
Shern-Ling Koh, Portfolio manager, Principal Global Investors
Tighter supply and inflation Analysts warn the supply of new grade A office buildings could slow this year, as high commodity prices, exacerbated by the Russia-Ukraine war, and expensive labour rates weigh on construction costs. Investors are keeping a wary eye on rising inflation, which has reached multi-year highs in many countries. Real estate has historically fared well during inflationary periods, with rents often linked to consumer price inflation indices (CPI). Indraneel Karlekar, global head of research and strategy at Principal Global Investors, said close scrutiny of buildings’ lease agreements is required though to see how regularly rent is reset. This can vary markedly both by sector and individual property. ‘Many leases have an explicit tie-in with CPI or other measures of inflation, so that can help provide some protection,’ he said. ‘But it does depend on how often that lease comes up for renewal. Sometimes office properties don’t have a break in their lease for three or five years.’ Inflation poses other challenges, Koh said, eating into real incomes and reducing consumer spending, meaning the landlords of retailers may not have the pricing power to raise rents. Sectors backed by secular growth trends, such as industrial buildings and data centres, should be able to outperform in an inflationary environment, Karlekar said. Siew adds that she expects property to remain popular with investors, who are attracted to its status as a traditional real asset in times of volatility. ‘The valuations of properties are driven by a mix of market comparables, income and cashflow analysis that may be better understood by investors,’ she said.
Investors remain underinvested in Asia Pacific property and there is strong conviction to increase exposure in 2022 with a real focus on larger deals and platform acquisitions
Stuart Crow CEO, capital markets, Asia Pacific, Jones Lang Lasalle
Yvonne Siew Head of real estate advisory and investments, Bank of Singapore
The valuations of properties are driven by a mix of market comparables, income and cashflow analysis that may be better understood by investors
Yvonne Siew, Bank of Singapore
Shern-Ling Koh Portfolio manager, Principal Global Investors
Indraneel Karlekar Global head of research and strategy, Principal Global Investors
How Asian investors can finetune their playbook for trading US equities
Hear from State Street Global Advisors’ Jean-François Mesnard-Sense, head of ETF capital market for Asia Pacific, and Viktor Östebo, head of institutional trading at Flow Traders, Asia, as they shine a light on the in’s and out’s of cross-border trading and lessons learned from a year marked by market upswings and record flows.
Disclaimer: For institutional / professional investors use only. The prospectus in respect of the offer of the units (the "Units") in the (SPDR® S&P 500 ETF Trust/SPDR® Dow Jones Industrial Average ETF Trust) (the "Fund") is available and may be obtained upon request from State Street Global Advisors Singapore Limited ("SSGA", Company Registration number: 200002719D). Investors should read the prospectus before deciding whether to acquire Units in the Fund. The value of Units and the income accruing to such Units may fall or rise. Units in the Fund are not obligations of, deposits in, or guaranteed by, SSGA or any of its affiliates. An investment in Units is subject to investment risks, including the possible loss of the principal amount invested. Past performance figures are not necessarily indicative of future performance of the Fund. Investors have no right to request SSGA to redeem their Units while the Units are listed. It is intended that holders of Units may only deal in their Units through trading on the Singapore Exchange Securities Trading Limited ("SGX-ST") or NYSE Arca Inc. (“NYSE Arca”). Listing of the Units on the SGX-ST or the NYSE Arca does not guarantee a liquid market for the Units. This advertisement or publication has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore. The statements and opinions expressed in this video are those of the author through the period ended January 31, 2022 and are subject to change based on market and other conditions.. State Street Global Advisors cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of any statements or data. Nothing in this publication constitutes investment advice and should not be relied upon as such. The value of units in the Funds may fall or rise. Listing of the Funds on the Singapore Stock Exchange (SGX) does not guarantee a liquid market for the units and the Fund may be delisted from the SGX. The Funds' Prospectus is available from State Street Global Advisors Singapore Limited or can be downloaded from ssga.com. All forms of investments carry risks, including the risk of losing all of the invested amount. Such activities may not be suitable for everyone. ETFs trade like stocks, are subject to investment risk, fluctuate in market value and may trade at prices above or below the ETFs net asset value. Brokerage commissions and ETF expenses will reduce returns. Standard & Poor’s, S&P and SPDR are registered trademarks of Standard & Poor’s Financial Services LLC(S&P); Dow Jones is a registered trademark of Dow Jones Trademark Holdings LLC (Dow Jones); and these trademarks have been licensed for use by S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC (SPDJI) and sublicensed for certain purposes by State Street Corporation. State Street Corporation’s financial products are not sponsored, endorsed, sold or promoted by SPDJI, Dow Jones, S&P, their respective affiliates and third party licensors and none of such parties make any representation regarding the advisability of investing in such product(s) nor do they have any liability in relation thereto, including for any errors, omissions, or interruptions of any index.
To learn more about accessing low-cost, highly liquid US equities solutions, visit State Street Global Advisors SPDR ETFs.
2021 was a record-breaking year for the exchange-traded fund (ETF) industry, with more than $1tn of net inflows globally—of which, more than $900bn went into US-listed ETFs and more than 50% of that going into US equity ETFs.[1] Given the popularity of these products globally, were they similarly well-received with Asian institutional investors? Mesnard-Sense: 2021 was indeed a banner year for ETFs. These investors are typically able to trade ETFs listed in the US, Europe and Asia, so it is hard to pin down which exposures they favoured. Having said that, there are proxies we can use to find out more about their preferred exposures. If we look at the range of US equity ETFs that State Street Global Advisors is managing in the region, assets under management increased by more than 55% last year.[2] Apart from anything else, that shows regional investors had a risk-on attitude and an appetite for US equities in 2021. The trading volume generated from regional investors, another proxy, has also increased significantly over the last few years. That is especially the case for Singapore, where the trading volume has more than quadrupled since 2019. What does that mean for the trading behaviour of Asian investors during Asian trading hours? And how are investors positioning themselves for best execution? Östebo: We mainly have requests for S&P 500, Nasdaq 100, Dow Jones and US equity ETFs. Investors who want their trades implemented as soon as possible usually go for a live risk price, while those without time constraints tend to go for the upcoming NAV price. After the Covid-19 market turmoil in 2020, however, we have noticed investors’ trading behaviour trending towards more digital modes. Where many once used agents, investors are increasingly using more modern methods of trading based on electronic request-for-quote (RFQ) systems. As the name suggests, an RFQ allows investors to request quotes from multiple price makers and choose the most competitive one. RFQ is the future and will gradually become dominant in Asia for a simple reason: prices are more competitive than old-school alternatives and trades benefits from better implementation time. Additionally, RFQ trading, lowers transaction costs, tightens the spread and is, all in all, operationally more efficient. How can Asian investors benefit from trading US equity ETFs during Asian trading hours? Are there any instances where it makes more sense to wait for US markets to open? Mesnard-Sense: Let me start by stating the obvious: if you are based in Asia and you trade during Asian hours, you do not have to stay up late at night. And not all investors may have the global capabilities to do that. Convenience, then, is definitely one advantage. You must not forget either that there is also liquidity available during Asian hours, which is something regional investors can benefit from. Even so, some regional investors may not know they can trade US-listed ETFs during Asian hours, so it may never be a consideration for them. That is where we come in: State Street Global Advisors offers capital market services that offer investors with trading and execution insights during Asian trading hours. Östebo: We did a study on this very topic and found the risk price available during US trading hours is only two to three basis points tighter than during Asian morning hours. However, the price move that Asian-based investors can be exposed to by waiting so long is around 70 basis points.3 That is not only a significant implementation shortfall but also an opportunity cost. If investors want to lower the implementation and opportunity costs while also reducing the risk, they have two options to consider. Either ask price makers for a live risk price during local Asian daytime hours, preferably via an electronic RFQ tool like Bloomberg RFQ or Tradeweb, or use Asia-listed ETFs or the cross-listings of US ETFs that are available locally. For example, cross-listings of SPY and DIA are available on the Singapore Exchange and both of them are highly tradable, especially if investors adopt the RFQ model. Have you seen more trading activity on cross-listings in Asia? Mesnard-Sense: Yes. Looking at the range we manage at State Street Global Advisors in Asia Pacific, the trading volume for US equity ETFs more than tripled between 2019 and 2021, and that trend is set to continue. One of the reasons may be that local listings are publicly available source of information, so investors are able to monitor prices in real time. Another reason is accessibility. Not everyone is able to trade the US market during US trading hours; some investors may only be able to do so locally. Finally, some listings are also available in the local currency, which may provide an additional benefit for certain investors looking to trade in local denominations. From a cost perspective, is it better for an investor to trade the primary listing in the US or the Asian cross-listings during Asian hours? Östebo: I wouldn’t say one is better than the other, but the spreads are different. For example, if you compare SPY US with its Singaporean equivalent SPY SP, there is no price difference. But if you are comparing spreads, you are looking at a wider spread of about two to four basis points in the Asian session compared to the US session. What exactly does that mean? Östebo: If the spread difference on an ETF you want to trade is 1% between Asian and US hours, and the average price move is 0.5% only, executing that ETF in Asian hours is probably not ideal. US small caps are an example of that, with wide spreads in Asian hours and tight spreads during US hours.[3] If, however, the spread difference is only three basis points, as is the case with SPY, and the average price movement from now until the US session is 70 basis points, it makes sense to trade during Asian hours. I am not saying that all globally listed ETFs should be traded in Asian hours, but in the case of US blue-chip equity, for example, the liquidity during Asian daytime is very good. Being able to reduce that opportunity cost is very compelling in my view.
Source: [1] Bloomberg L.P., January 31, 2022. [2] State Street Global Advisors, January 31, 2022. [3] Flow Traders, December 31, 2021.
Jean-François Mesnard-Sense Head of ETF capital market for Asia Pacific, State Street Global Advisors
Viktor Östebo Head of institutional trading Flow Traders, Asia
Ultra-high-net-worth clients are increasingly, and impressively, pursuing ESG investments for reputational gain as much as financial. They are ever more discerning about the investment managers with whom they place their capital as well as the exposures they run. This is particularly evident in private market allocations, where the investment relationship is long term and clients think more carefully about how their exposures will transpire 8-10 years from now. ESG adoption in Asia has been slower, particularly compared with Europe and the US, but private clients now recognise ESG as one of the clear policy directives in China and see opportunities along each of the environmental, social and governance trends. Indeed venture philanthropy is fast becoming an ESG investing movement. At Morgan Stanley PWM, we like to partner with private equity managers who have long subscribed to high ESG standards being critical to value creation. For example, one of our Chinese venture capital managers has invested in advanced environmental technologies for 20 years. That same manager participates in community outreach schemes with its portfolio companies and emphasises diversity, inclusion and financial emancipation in its operating environment. Ultimately ESG disclosure requirements and regulation in the region will be critical to the development of investment products, and intentional ESG engagement and activism strategies will be the ones that resonate strongest with our astute clients.
Many investors may feel they wake up every day faced with a new set of surprises in the global financial markets. So where can investors take refuge? Some will choose to stay on the sidelines, while others shift their mindsets. Looking beyond the public markets, opportunities abound in the less liquid private markets. An interesting facet is that there is a growing subset of investors who are increasingly inclined to tilt their investments towards generating positive social and environmental impact, while still aiming for attractive financial returns. Some of this shift can be attributed to the widely cited fact that $30tn is estimated to be inherited by millennials from their baby boomer parents in the coming decades. Millennials, with their increased fire power and influence, are twice as likely to invest in a manner that will reflect their views on global challenges, such as climate change and social inequality. When it comes to ESG, much has been written on environmental issues and climate change. It may seem vague, if not overly altruistic, but social inequality can also be addressed through private markets exposure. Financial inclusion is considered a key enabler to the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals and fintech as a sector is likely to be a big equaliser. Fintech as a private market investment opportunity is booming around the world, while emerging markets remain under-banked and with limited access to even the most mainstream financial services. In developed markets fintechs are primarily competing with traditional financial institutions or enabling them, but fintechs in emerging markets are unlocking access to a set of financial solutions that consumers and SMEs had never accessed before. Julius Baer has partnered with a manager who is capturing the transformative power of technological change sweeping across emerging markets and has a strong track record of generating attractive returns.
by Koye Sun
Popular views
chapter five
A rising number of private markets investment providers issue sustainable investment and environmental, social and governance (ESG) integration policies which integrate these factors in their investment process. This also allows some of them to seek an Article 8 classification under the EU’s Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation. Private markets can also provide access to asset classes that can meet ESG concerns. For example, the energy transition requires strong infrastructure investments ranging from electric networks for electric vehicles to the development of cleaner energy such as wind and solar to improvements of current water infrastructure. Those investments are often difficult to find through listed investments and private markets therefore have a key role to play. Moreover, as investors in such projects it is much easier to have a seat at the management table and have the ability to exert influence.
In Pictet’s alternative investment activities, we are convinced that ESG considerations can help our clients make better long-term investment decisions. As such, ESG is at the core of our investment processes. Given our multiple business activities when it comes to private markets, our engagement will slightly differ based on the level of our control. In our manager selection business, we have developed a dedicated ESG questionnaire to assess, among other things, our partners’ commitment to ESG and their level of engagement on that front, in their processes, operations and ownership. Using an internal scoring methodology, we rank investments and report findings. We actively engage where we see areas of improvement. In our private equity co-investment activities, we would already exclude any business that is not compliant with Pictet Group’s exclusion policies. We then review a set of ESG criteria incorporating general partner-led analysis, external adviser reports as well as those key performance indicators defined by the ESG Data Convergence Project. In our direct real estate business, we have developed a proprietary ESG framework which tackles four specific pillars across each investment: energy, well-being, operations and transparency. Each pillar has its own set of ESG objectives to be implemented at asset level. ESG improvement is part of our value creation strategy and progress is regularly reported to investors.
Donald Rice Head of fund specialists Asia, Julius Baer
Christina Au-Yeung Co-head of investment management services, Morgan Stanley Private Wealth Management Asia
Gregoire de Rham Head of alternative investments Asia, Pictet Wealth Management
Nicolas Mougeot Head of global trends and ESG advisory, Indosuez Wealth Management
A vox pop for our sustainable times: How do you marry clients’ ESG concerns with private market investments?